Key takeaways
- Wood is warm and traditional, composite is lower in maintenance.
- Framing matters as much as the surface boards.
- Think about sun, shade, pets, bare feet and how you will use the deck.
- Plan for upkeep: staining wood, cleaning composite.
Pressure-treated and cedar
Pressure-treated pine is widely available and strong, and with a good sealer it can serve for many seasons. Cedar is lighter, naturally rot resistant and takes stain beautifully but is softer and usually more expensive to buy. Both need sealing or staining to look their best.
Wood can crack, cup and gray if left unprotected in the Tennessee sun and rain.
Composite and PVC decking
Composite boards combine wood fiber and plastic, and PVC boards are all plastic. Both resist rot and insects and rarely need staining. They can get hot in direct sun, scratch and show the occasional mildew, and the up-front spend is higher than for wood.
Look for boards with a protective cap and check the manufacturer rules for spacing and fasteners.
The frame under the boards
No matter what you choose for the surface, the frame decides how long the deck lasts. Footings, posts, beams, joists, flashing and the connection to the house all have to be built correctly. Many composite makers require tighter joist spacing than wood decks do.
A common reference is the American Wood Council deck construction guide, which many inspectors recognize.
Living with your deck
Wood decks need a wash and a fresh coat every couple of years, while composite needs regular cleaning. Consider sun and shade, bare feet, pets, furniture and how much time you want to spend on upkeep. For many homeowners in Nashville, the choice comes down to budget now versus time later.
A mixed approach, such as composite boards with wood rails, is common.
Official sources and further reading
- American Wood Council deck construction guide (DCA 6)
- American Wood Council
- International Code Council
These are independent organizations. Links open in a new tab.
Quick answers
Can I put composite on my old frame?
Sometimes. The frame must be sound and spaced for the boards. We check the joists and ledger first.
Which lasts longer?
A well built deck with good materials of any type can last. Frame quality and care matter more than the label.




